It presumes that governments, authority figures, institutions, and mass media are forcing ideas on regular people from the top down. That term, however, comes with historical baggage. In fact, we have a very old word for persuasive communication with an agenda: propaganda. They imply that a narrative or claim has deviated from a stable or canonical truth whether Pelosi should go is simply a matter of opinion. Confronted with campaigns to make certain ideas seem more widespread than they really are, many researchers and media commentators have taken to using labels such as “misinformation” and “disinformation.” But those terms have fallen victim to scope creep. Through my work at the Internet Observatory, I’d witnessed many attempts to push messages by gaming the algorithms that Twitter, Facebook, and other platforms use to identify popular content and surface it to users. Then I made a pot of coffee and waited to see whether Buttar’s supporters could pull it off. “Did you see this?” I asked a colleague at the Stanford Internet Observatory over Slack, dropping the anonymous call to action into the channel.
I wondered whether the online armies would turn out for him. Team Buttar’s message was sent at 10:30 a.m. But on Twitter that Sunday morning, the challenger had a more promising strategy: If the ploy worked, his slogan would show up on millions of screens across the entire country without costing him a dime. The day before, incensed at Pelosi’s refusal to debate him, he had sparred with an unoccupied chair outdoors on a public street. I was living in San Francisco then and had been following Buttar’s efforts to get attention, as traditional outlets largely ignored the democratic socialist’s underdog campaign. Don’t use more than two hashtags-otherwise you’ll be marked as spam.” The call to action urged people to start posting at noon Pacific time, attach their favorite graphics, and like and retweet other Buttar supporters’ contributions. “Shahid Says…,” read the large print, “Draft some tweets with #PelosiMustGo-don’t forget to capitalize #EachWord.
PROPAGANDA FOR W2K19 HOW TO
It contained an image of Shahid Buttar, the San Francisco activist challenging House Speaker Nancy Pelosi in the 2020 congressional runoff, and offered explicit instructions for how to elevate the hashtag #PelosiMustGo to the nationwide Trending list on Twitter.
O ne Sunday morning in July of last year, a message from an anonymous account appeared on “Bernie or Vest,” a Discord chat server for fans of Senator Bernie Sanders. About the author: Renée DiResta is the technical research manager at the Stanford Internet Observatory.